Is Any Job Better Than No Job?
Women in the workforce are constantly being urged to climb the social ladder and work in an industry that challenges them. After all, women deserve the same opportunities to work in a position and for a company that they love. However, this idea is slowing shifting—for both men and women.
In a bad economy, it is especially tough to find the job of your dreams. Everyone hopes to secure a position in a successful company where they can further their career and learn new business practices, but this is becoming increasingly difficult. More individuals are finding themselves in the situation of accepting a job that is unrelated to their work experience or field of study. However, as bills are approaching and interviews are decreasing, the prospect of taking any job seems more and more attractive; regardless of whether or not you can use the skills you have acquired over years of working and schooling. This led me to wonder: In this economy, should you settle for less than your best?
Before deciding to make a commitment with the first company that offers you a job, you should weigh the pros and cons of the decision:
Settle-for-Less Pros:
- Income: The most important aspect of a job is that you’ll have a steady stream of income. The more responsibilities you have, such as family, auto insurance, or loans, the more a stable income will be important.
- Experience: Any job, no matter what field or industry, will give you the chance to learn new skills and develop proficiencies. Even if the job you’re offered seems useless to your larger career goals, you may pick up experience that will prove useful in future positions.
- Security: Your income gives you stability in times of recession. In addition, there’s always a chance that your position may lead to promotion and therefore a more permanent position. Knowing that you have a job when finding a job is so uncertain will help put your worries to rest.
Take-the-Job Cons:
- Unrelated Field: Your job may not be related to your field of study or past experience. While it is true you may learn things that will help you in the future, there is a chance this job will teach you little. This may have a negative effect on your career path when you apply for future jobs; not to mention you may feel like you’re wasting your time with a job that will not help you get ahead. For example, my friend spends her days fixing business phone services when she specializes in selling health insurance. Needless to say, she isn’t thrilled.
- Dissatisfaction: If your job is not in your field of interest or does not pay you a comparative salary, then you may become discouraged and unhappy. Not only will you be unhappy that your job is not leading to better things, but doing the actual job itself is likely to be very uninteresting.
- Lack of Freedom: If your current position requires you to work a standard work week, then your ability to interview for other jobs decreases. As you dedicate more time to your current job, it reduces the opportunities that you can apply for other jobs.
If you’re still confused about whether taking any job is the right decision in this economy, you should consider your situation and whether you have options that allow you to wait. Here are a few questions that may help you decide whether you should wait for the right job or get working immediately:
5 Questions to Ask Before You Accept Any Old Job Offer
1. Do you have any savings?
If you have savings that can last you one year, you can try to dedicate more time interviewing and looking for jobs that are related to your field. If you truly devote 40 hours per week to finding a job in your field, you are much more likely to find that dream job. Plus, your pay will likely be higher than if you were to take any old job offer.
2. Are you willing to travel?
You may have to travel further, or even relocate to work at a preferred job. Ask yourself whether or not this is something you are willing to do. If you are not willing to travel for a good job, then your options are much more limited; therefore taking any job might be the solution. After all, beggars can’t be choosers.
3. Are you looking for a temporary or permanent position?
If you are simply looking for a temp position, you may be able to struggle through working at a job that is not in your field. Jobs are now hard to come by, so unless you’re looking for something long-term, I would suggest taking an unrelated job if the opportunity arises.
4. Do you have any contacts?
One of the most common ways in which people find jobs is through networking. Ask everyone you know whether their company is hiring, and if they can refer you to a position that is suited for you. If you have a lot of contacts, your chances of getting that dream job are much higher, so it may be worth it to wait.
5. How badly do you need the job?
This question is ultimately a deciding factor on whether you should take any job in a recession. If you’re in a dire financial situation with no savings and desperately need a source of income, or if you have no family to give you a place to stay while you look for a job, any job will temporarily fulfill that need for an income. But if you can wait out a little longer, then you can continue to interview and hopefully land the job of your dreams.
Whether you are a woman or a man, finding that job is no longer an easy task. Weigh the pros and cons and ask yourself a few of the questions above before making any rash decisions. The important thing to remember is not to let your pride get to you. Thousands of people each day are accepting jobs which do not use their education or their professional skills. Everyone knows the economy is hard—just make the decision that is right for you.
Photo Credit : dailyrosetta.com
A very timely post not only relevant for times of recession. Many people can use this checklist even during the best of times. I am a big believer that one should keep working and not coast for the best thing to just show up. You’ll gain experiences no matter where you are at. A valuable piece of advise especially for folks just coming into the working world.
Thank you Julie! I know I have a lot of friends just joining the working world who are dealing with this issue (why I was inspired to write the article). I also agree coasting is never a good idea. Thanks for the advice! @JulieG
I am so pleased to see so many great comments on my post! This is the first time I’ve written for bizchickblogs, and I have quickly realized I need to check up on comments more often!
I was particularly touched by John’s story about the women working with an abusive boss. The thing, she could probably win a lot of money in a lawsuit if she could prove the abuse, but who has money to pay a lawyer and go through the court systems? It absolutely horrifies me that people are having to allow themselves to get hurt simply because jobs are so hard to find. I can’t sit here and say that this women should do nothing, but there has to be another way. With that said: John, I hope that you advise your friend to look for a different job, regardless whether or not it is in her field or can further her career. No job is worth abuse.
On a different note, it’s great to hear that going a different route has worked for some of you! It’s terrible to think that you do not get hired because you have too much experience, and I think many deal with this depressed feeling that Red talked about. I think this is why blog posts like this are good–we realize that so many people are struggling with this issue. It is absolutely depressing, but there is hope in the end. Desperation can cloud someone’s judgement, so all we can do is rise above.
If I can be of any help in the future, please let me know! Feel free to follow me on Twitter (@A_DiSilvestro) or email me (Amanda.DiSilvestro@business.com). I am obviously a writer, and there is some hope in this field when it comes to freelance writing, so I’d be happy to point you to some articles I’ve written on this subject =)
It is so tough finding a job out there. Forget about “decent” job, I’m just talking about any old job.
I have a friend that is working with an abusive boss right now, and we try all the time to find something else for her, but her and her husband are struggling with their house and bills bills bills so she can’t just walk off the job.
The thing is, she isn’t making that much there, so we thought it would be simple, but man we pore over the paper, job boards, local organizations, just word of mouth, too. She’s an older lady, too, so I’m sure this is playing a part in things, but it is tough to find *anything* out there.
My sister works at a local library, and she tells me they have to police the internet access every day because desperate people are in there lining up to check their emails and apply to jobs. I really think people will just take anything now days so they can regain some measure of self-respect and just get some money coming in no matter how little it might be.
Of course then I read things about employers not wanting to hire people who are unemployed. Huh?? I’m not sure how we’re supposed to get back on track if the people who need jobs can’t get hired because they’re not employed.
Alright enough rambling (for now). Great post, Amanda!
I agree with Tia completely. If a person needs a job, because of lack of money or any other reason, then he or she will definitely find it, even if it doesn’t relate to the appropriate field. I can agree that sometimes it’s difficult to find a job that meets all your requirements and wishes, but any other you can…
Hi Amanda, Being honest with yourself and putting pride aside is good advice for sure!
Short term and as a matter of survival I would have taken any job. I looked for a job for two and half years after being self employed for over twenty. Times have been so bad financially, for so long that I would have taken anything. Unfortunately, I was not hired because I’m too old, been out of the workforce, or over qualified. This was downright depressing. Hubby and I wondered if we would be able to keep our house. With a bit of dealing and juggling we managed to lower our monthly payments.
Contacts made all the difference, like you say, and finally work has begun to pick up. The profit is slim but better than zero! Had I been hired and working out of the home, we may not have been awarded those contracts. So everyone really does need to decide what fits them best. Knowing that others share in this financial dilemma somehow makes this a bit easier to accept!
Great post, Amanda! This is the conundrum many people are facing in this economy. I have lived and am currently living this situation. The catch is that I am building my business while I work my current job to pay the bills. It’s the means to a much better end, for me, at least. I love your 5 questions to ask before you take the job. Desperation can cloud our judgment, but if there is an end-goal in mind, then taking the less-than-ideal job for the “now” is a good strategy.
Hi Amanda – I couldn’t agree more with you that finding a job today is difficult. I believe that if your overall goals go way beyond working for someone else, than taking a job might just be a bridge that’s necessary to keep your house in order while working on your own business. For me, it was for both sanity and financial reasons. I took a job in a completely unrelated field, because I realized long ago that I didn’t like my related field anyway.
I also took this job to help me get some perspective. It provides money while I’m working things out in my head. For me, it was a great choice.
Comments on this entry are closed.